Investigating your own CEO: structure, independence and managing reputations

When the person under investigation is the chief executive, the usual way of running an internal inquiry no longer works. This is how general counsel and investigations lawyers can structure the work, protect its independence and look after the reputations of both the individual and the company.

Investigating your own CEO

Words by

Augmetec

A lot of internal investigations follow a familiar pattern. A concern is raised, the general counsel or head of compliance takes ownership, and a team working within the organisation’s normal reporting lines gathers the evidence and reports back. When the person under investigation is the chief executive, or another member of the senior leadership team, almost every part of that arrangement stops working. That is because the people who would normally run the investigation report, directly or indirectly, to the person at its centre.

These cases are rare, but anyone who runs or advises on investigations will recognise the difficulty the board now faces. The allegations are often serious, the subject usually stays in post while the work goes on, and regulators, investors and the press may be watching from the start. That means mistakes made in the first few days can be very hard to undo. Here’s advice on how to get it right.

Get the structure right first

The first task is to move ownership of the investigation away from management. In most companies that means a committee of independent directors overseeing the work, with outside counsel instructed by the committee to carry it out and in-house lawyers limited to a supporting role.

That structure then needs to be set down in terms of reference that record who sits on the committee, who counsel takes instructions from, what is in and out of scope, and who sees the findings first. Scope is usually the hardest part to get right. If it is drawn too narrowly, people will suspect the outcome was decided in advance, and if it is drawn too widely, an inquiry into a specific concern can turn into an examination of a senior executive’s entire professional and private life.

The committee should also expect to work to other people’s timetables, since results announcements, regulatory deadlines, political interest and press coverage rarely wait for an investigation to finish.

“As you delve into the allegations and agree the scope, the first thing you ought to do is decide who actually has sufficient information to brief you,” says Kyle Phillips, Partner, Business Crime and Regulatory, Howard Kennedy. “You also need to be very conscious of that person’s relationship with whoever is the subject of the investigation, because you don’t want anyone giving you tainted information, trying to steer the investigation or the subject being able to influence or direct the investigation in anyway.”

What boards need to think about early

In the first days after an allegation surfaces, the pressure to act quickly can lead a company to start gathering evidence before anyone has thought about privilege. Board members or HR begin asking questions, speaking to witnesses and collecting documents, and because no lawyer is involved, none of that work is privileged. If the matter later becomes a civil claim, a regulatory inquiry or a criminal investigation, the notes, interviews and early findings may all have to be handed over.

Phillips says the most common way companies trip up on privilege is simply failing to bring lawyers in.

“Legal professional privilege can only be obtained if you have lawyers in place," Phillips explains. "If someone from a team within the company or somebody on the board starts asking questions, speaking to witnesses and instructing experts without a lawyer involved, this will not be protected by legal advice privilege or litigation privilege.”

“Where there’s a risk of civil claims, regulatory action or, at worst, criminal enforcement, you want to be in control of the narrative and of the documents,” he adds. “The minute you lose privilege, you’ve lost that control.”

The practical answer is to bring lawyers in before any investigative work begins, and to decide at the outset who will be told about the allegations, since every extra person in the circle of trust is another route by which the matter can leak.

Make independence visible

Independence has to be visible to outsiders, and a useful test is whether a regulator, a court or a sceptical journalist would accept that the subject had no influence over the outcome. In practice that means keeping executives who report to the CEO away from decisions about the investigation and, ideally, instructing a firm other than the company’s usual advisers, so that nobody can suggest counsel had a relationship to protect.

The same thinking applies to the evidence. If the chief executive’s emails, phones and travel records are collected by an IT team that reports to the chief executive, their integrity can be challenged before anyone has read them, so collection should sit with people outside that reporting line and every access, search and decision should be recorded. Where the subject remains in post, the committee also has to decide what they can see, who speaks for the company on the matter and how witnesses are protected from pressure, whether real or perceived.

“Independence is about showing a genuine separation between the company and the organisation instructed to carry out the investigation, which in most cases will be an external one,” says Kritin Sundaram, CEO and co-founder of Augmetec. “That means taking instructions from someone inside the business who has no connection to the allegation, and being able to show that the whole process, from start to finish, was thorough and defensible, with no outside factor influencing any decision.”

Protect the individual and the company

Two reputations are at stake, and their interests do not always align. The company needs to show that it is taking the matter seriously, while the individual is entitled to a fair process and to have their private life kept separate from the question under investigation. A fair process is what protects both, so the subject should understand what is being examined, have a proper chance to respond and have their own legal representation where needed, and company counsel should make clear at the start of each interview that they act for the company.

Communications matter just as much. A short, carefully worded statement that describes the investigation without characterising the subject, and that the board can stand behind for weeks rather than days, is usually safer than a fuller account that may later need correcting. Because a leak can damage both reputations faster than anything else, need-to-know access and a clear record of who has seen what are as much a part of protecting reputations as they are of good administration.

Scrutiny is also far greater than in an ordinary internal matter. “When the subject is a chief executive, the reputations of both the individual and the organisation have to be managed throughout, and a complete record of every step is what allows you to answer to all of those audiences," says Sundaram.

“Where a lot of internal investigations go wrong is that people don’t think about the human side of it,” adds Phillips. “Ensure appropriate safeguards are in place for anyone involved and ensure the investigation is impartial, independent and balanced. You have to come in with an open mind and make sure people have a proper chance to give their side of the story.”

Where AI helps, and where it shouldn’t

An investigation like this can involve years of messages, calendars, travel and expense records across several languages and jurisdictions, all of which has to be reviewed while external deadlines approach, and this is where AI is most useful. With everything held and indexed in one place, investigators can ask questions in plain English across the whole case and get answers that cite their sources, draw context from all of the evidence at once rather than relying on reviewers who have each seen only their own batch of documents, go back through historic records, build a timeline of meetings and contacts, and flag documents that may have been altered. A well-designed platform also keeps a single record linking the evidence, the decisions and the use of AI itself, so that the committee can show how it reached its conclusions. In a matter this sensitive, it should also be clear where the data is held and that none of it will be used to train anyone else’s model.

The decisions themselves should stay with people. Assessing credibility, conducting interviews and reaching findings all depend on human judgement, and in an investigation into a chief executive, where every step will be scrutinised, a finding that nobody can explain is worth very little.

“LEIAA automatically captures every step of the investigation and every action taken by each person working on it,” says Sundaram. “It can sift through millions of documents in minutes to find the material that matters, which would otherwise take weeks or months, or just simply wouldn’t be possible.”

“In addition to that, there is a human in the loop at every step. The technology makes suggestions based on the source evidence, and they are only ever suggestions or recommendations. People are involved at every stage to verify the outputs and to bring the expert insight, strategic thinking and experience that an investigation like this demands.”

The real test comes at the end

At the end of any investigation of a senior executive, a tough moment is when the findings arrive and the board has to explain them in a way that people believe. That credibility cannot be added at the end, because it is built from the first week onwards, through the choices about who runs the work, what they examine and how each step is recorded.

“When the findings are challenged, the question is always whether anything was missed or whether anything weighed too heavily,” says Sundaram. “If you can show that no stone was left unturned, and exactly how each decision was reached, the findings will hold.”

Welcome to the future of investigations

SIGN UP FOR UPDATES FROM OUR TEAM

© Augmetec Limited 2026

Augmetec Limited is a company registered in England and Wales with Company Number 14244375 and registered address at 71-75 Shelton Street, London, WC2H 9JQ, UK

Welcome to the future of investigations

SIGN UP FOR UPDATES FROM OUR TEAM

© Augmetec Limited 2026

Augmetec Limited is a company registered in England and Wales with Company Number 14244375 and registered address at 71-75 Shelton Street, London, WC2H 9JQ, UK

Welcome to the future of investigations

SIGN UP FOR UPDATES FROM OUR TEAM

© Augmetec Limited 2026

Augmetec Limited is a company registered in England and Wales with Company Number 14244375 and registered address at 71-75 Shelton Street, London, WC2H 9JQ, UK